LSAT Reading Comprehension: Should You Highlight? Try This Test

On LSAT Reading Comprehension, most people do better when they mark less: fewer highlights, fewer notes on the scratch paper, and a quicker first read that leaves more time for the questions. The 3-passage test below shows you whether over-marking is costing you points, and what to read for instead.

If Reading Comprehension is your weak section, you might be doing too much on it. By too much I mean too much highlighting and rereading. I say this a lot and people are usually surprised, because RC feels like the section where you're supposed to slow down and be extra careful.

When I studied for the LSAT I did the same thing. I learned all kinds of complicated note-taking strategies and kept myself busy underlining, circling and highlighting, mostly because it was the only way I could make myself pay attention to mind-numbingly boring passages. Unfortunately, most of it didn't help at all.

The 3-passage highlight test

Before changing anything, try this on your next 3 timed passages, ideally on LawHub so it's the same setup you'll have on test day. Keep a tally of every mark you make: highlights, underlines, anything you write on the scratch paper. Then, after the questions, count how many of those marks you actually went back to and used to pick an answer. Be strict. A quick glance along the way doesn't count. If you want practice passages on topics that might come back, my LSAT predictions page has my Reading Comp calls for each test, graded afterward.

Also jot down the time left on the countdown timer when you start reading, when you finish reading, and when you finish the questions.

If you didn't use most of your marks and you were rushing the last couple of questions, that's probably where you're losing points. With heavy markers, that's usually what I see. As a rough guide, I'd spend about a third of a passage's time on the read and the rest on its questions, though some fast readers do fine spending more.

Why marking costs more on a computer

The LSAT is on a computer now, and that makes every mark more expensive than it was on paper. Each highlight means selecting the text and then picking a style from a little pop-up, and your reading stops while you do it. (The highlight tool is a bit glitchy anyway.)

Writing on the scratch paper has its own cost. Your eyes leave the screen, you write, and then you have to find your place again. A lot of Reading Comprehension habits, and a lot of older prep books, were built for the paper test, when an underline was basically free.

Most of the strongest RC people I've worked with mark very little, and some don't mark anything. It could be that good readers just don't need marks, but I see it a lot.

What to read for instead

A lot of people are scared of missing details, so they read everything really carefully, and they keep missing the bigger points.

My usual advice is that if what you're doing isn't working, you try the opposite for a while and see what happens. Stop worrying about the details and read for the big picture, meaning the main idea, where the author stands, and why the passage is even there.

The details you can always go back for. On the first read, just notice roughly where they are (the examples are in paragraph 2, the study is at the end of paragraph 3, that kind of thing) and keep going.

Where to slow down: the author's turn

Don't skim the author's view, though. When people stop marking they sometimes start skimming, and the author's view is the first thing they lose track of.

You'll see passages that spend 2 long paragraphs on a view that sounds really convincing, and then in paragraph 3 the author turns around and critiques it. A lot of the questions come from that switch, and the wrong answers are built for people who think the convincing view was the author's. That's where I slow down, and if I mark anything at all, it's that spot.

The turn is usually a simple "but" or "however," sometimes "yet" or "still," and it often comes right after the author has spent a while being fair to the other side ("admittedly," "to be sure"). The hard ones often have no signal word at all, so the real habit to build is asking whose view each paragraph is giving you.

This comes up with high scorers too. One asked me for quick Reading Comprehension tips, and they were spending a long time carefully reading each passage before touching a question. I told them to keep notes minimal, not lean on the highlighter, and shorten the read so the questions get more time. At that level the misses tend to be the hardest questions, and those are the ones that need the time.

What order to do the questions in

I do the big-picture questions first (main point, primary purpose, the author's attitude), then the ones that point you to specific lines, then inference last. If you came out of the read knowing the main idea and where the author stands, the big-picture ones usually go fast.

A lot of RC inference questions ask what's most strongly supported, or what the author would most likely agree with. So the right answer can be a small step past what the passage says outright, not always a word-for-word match. It still needs support in the text. But if you treat every one like a must-be-true question from Logical Reasoning, you can end up throwing out the right answer because you're looking for proof that isn't there. I go deeper on this in Reading Comprehension inference and main point questions.

When to keep your marking system

If you already score well with a marking system and your count shows you really use most of what you mark, keep doing it. Don't change a working system because a blog post told you to.

How to practice it

Stop doing RC passages on your phone. Test day is on a computer, so do your timed work on one too, on LawHub with the real highlight tool, so nothing about it surprises you on test day.

For extra reading, skip the magazines and read real LSAT passages. Save the newer ones for timed work. Read the older ones casually, on the couch or before bed. After each one, say the main idea and the author's view in your own words before you look at the questions, then do only the main point question. If your version doesn't match the right answer, go find the sentence you skimmed past.

I've been coaching the LSAT since 2005, and this is still the change I see help the most people on Reading Comprehension.

Frequently asked questions

Should you highlight on LSAT Reading Comprehension?

Mark very little. Each on-screen highlight takes a few clicks and stops your reading. If you mark anything, mark the spot where the author turns against a view, because that's where a lot of the questions come from.

Should you take notes on scratch paper during Reading Comprehension?

Keep them to a few words, if any. Every note pulls your eyes off the screen and makes you find your place again. Notice where the details sit and go back for them when a question asks.

How long should you spend reading an LSAT passage?

As a rough guide, about a third of the passage's time on the read and the rest on its questions. If your timer check shows the read eating half or more and you're rushing the last questions, shorten the read first.

How do you find the author's view in a Reading Comprehension passage?

Ask whose view each paragraph is giving you. Watch for a "but," "however," "yet," or "still" right after the author has been fair to the other side ("admittedly," "to be sure"), and slow down there. The hardest turns have no signal word, so the question matters more than the words.

Go deeper

For the short list of what to study, grab my free LSAT cheat sheet.

Enough reading. Try a question. Free LSAT drills, 1 at a time, explained the second you answer. Start free drills

Get the LSAT Unplugged app

Your drills and your progress, on your phone.

Download on the App Store Get it on Google Play

Add LSAT Unplugged to ChatGPT or Claude for real law school numbers.

Scan with your phone